See how a starting pot and regular contributions grow over time — and exactly what reinvesting your dividends adds versus spending them. Over decades the gap is bigger than almost anyone expects. Free, no signup, monthly compounding.
Returns are before inflation, so these figures are in future pounds, not today's.
Two scenarios, same money, one difference — whether the dividends are reinvested or taken as cash and spent.
FV = start × (1 + r)^years + monthly × [((1 + m)^(12·years) − 1) / m]
The full total return r compounds, because the dividends buy more units that themselves earn returns. m is the equivalent monthly rate, so contributions paid in through the year compound too.
rₛ = r − dividend yield → the pot grows on price alone.
If the dividends are withdrawn and spent, only the price growth compounds. The pot still rises, just more slowly — and the two lines steadily pull apart. On these assumptions, that gap is what reinvesting adds.
Inside a Stocks & Shares ISA or SIPP the reinvested dividends are tax-free. In a general account they count as income the year they’re paid (2026/27: first £500 free, then 10.75%, 35.75% or 39.35% depending on your band), which reduces what is left to reinvest. The calculator models that — switch Where is it held? to a general account and the figures above move.
Reinvesting is the same decision wherever you hold the money. What changes is how much of each dividend survives to be reinvested.
Here is the bit most calculators miss, because most of them are American. The first £500 of dividends each year is tax-free, so a smaller portfolio pays nothing at all. The drag starts at zero and then builds as the pot grows past the allowance — which is exactly why it is worth seeing rather than guessing at.
The £500 covers this much of a portfolio before a penny of dividend tax is due:
| Dividend yield | Portfolio the allowance covers |
|---|---|
| 2.0% — typical global tracker | £25,000 |
| 2.5% | £20,000 |
| 3.0% — higher yield | £16,667 |
| 4.0% — income tilt | £12,500 |
Same plan either way: £50,000 to start, £500 a month, 25 years, a 7% total return with 2.5% of it coming from dividends, all of them reinvested.
| Where it is held | After 25 years | Cost of the wrapper |
|---|---|---|
| Stocks & Shares ISA or SIPP | £662,893 | — |
| General account, basic rate | £634,401 | —£28,491 |
| General account, higher rate | £573,384 | —£89,508 |
| General account, additional rate | £565,165 | —£97,728 |
At higher rate that is £89,508, and only £49,528 of it is the tax itself. The rest is the growth that tax would have earned had it stayed invested — the same compounding that makes reinvesting work, running in reverse.
The tax comes out of the pot each year. If you pay it from other money the pot is larger, but you are that much poorer elsewhere — the cost is the same, it just sits somewhere the chart cannot see.
The £500 allowance is treated as covering these dividends only. Hold dividend-paying investments elsewhere and it is shared between them, so the drag would be larger. Your band is set by your total income, not by the dividends alone.
Spending the dividends does not avoid the tax. In a general account they are taxable whether you reinvest them or take the cash, so the orange line is unchanged — you simply receive less than it shows.
And a SIPP is tax-free on the dividends, not on the way out: withdrawals are taxed as income, with 25% normally tax-free. An ISA is the one that is free at both ends.
The reinvested line isn't a little higher — it's a different curve. Each reinvested dividend buys units that pay their own dividends, so the effect compounds on compounding. Early on the two paths look almost identical; the gap only becomes dramatic in the final third, which is exactly why starting early and leaving it alone matters more than picking the perfect fund.
Three things move the gap most: time (drag the years slider and watch the final third explode), the dividend yield (a higher-yielding, income-tilted portfolio has more to reinvest), and keeping it sheltered so tax doesn't skim the reinvested dividends each year. For the full picture on wrappers, funds and the honest risks, read the investing guide.