As a sole trader, the business and you are the same person for tax. The profit is added to your other income and taxed as yours: income tax at your rates, on top of your pay, plus Class 4 National Insurance at 6% on profit between £12,570 and £50,270 and 2% above. You pay it all through Self Assessment, whether you spend the money or leave it in the bank.
Through a limited company, the company is taxed first. It pays corporation tax on its profit: 19% up to £50,000, 25% from £250,000, and a rate in between with marginal relief. What is left belongs to the company. You pay tax only on what you take out. A salary is a cost to the company, with employee and employer National Insurance on it above their thresholds. Dividends come out of profit that has already paid corporation tax, and they are taxed on you at 10.75%, 35.75% or 39.35% after a £500 allowance. Dividends carry no National Insurance.
If you have a job, it matters where the extra income lands. Your pay fills your personal allowance and the basic-rate band first, so anything from the business sits on top of it.
Worked example: a £41,000 job and £10,000 of profit
England, 2026/27, everything taken out of the company as dividends in the same year, no salary or pension from the company.
| Sole trader | Limited company | |
|---|---|---|
| Business profit | £10,000 | £10,000 |
| Corporation tax at 19% | None | £1,900 |
| Income tax on the profit | £2,146 | None |
| Class 4 National Insurance | £0 | None |
| Dividend tax on £8,100 | None | £817 |
| Total tax | £2,146 | £2,717 |
| What you keep | £7,854 | £7,283 |
The job uses the whole £12,570 personal allowance and £28,430 of the £37,700 basic-rate band. As a sole trader, the first £9,270 of profit is taxed at 20% (£1,854) and the last £730 at 40% (£292). The profit is under £12,570, so there is no Class 4. Through the company, corporation tax takes £1,900, leaving £8,100 to pay out. The first £500 is covered by the dividend allowance and the other £7,600 all fits in the basic-rate band at 10.75%, which is £817. On these figures the sole trader keeps £571 more.
The same job with £30,000 of profit
As a sole trader, income tax is £10,146 (£9,270 at 20%, then £20,730 at 40%) and Class 4 is £1,046, so you keep £18,808. Through the company, corporation tax is £5,700 and £24,300 is paid out, with £6,316 of dividend tax because most of it lands in the higher-rate band at 35.75%. You keep £17,984. The gap is £824 this year.
If the company paid out only £9,270, the dividends would stay in the basic-rate band and cost £943 in tax. You would keep £8,327 this year and £15,030 would stay in the company. That money has paid corporation tax but not yet dividend tax, which is due in whichever year it comes out, at that year's rates. That is why the calculator shows what is left in the company separately rather than adding it to what you keep.
What the sum cannot tell you
A one-year comparison leaves out the cost of running a company, the protection of limited liability, how long you expect the business to last, what your income will be in the years you take money out, and rules such as IR35. Those can matter as much as the tax. The calculator above lays out the arithmetic for your figures; an accountant can put it together with the rest.